As Sara Fridell says and I add, Wilde used double identity as well as a dualistic theme in the play, revealed in the language and in the strategies of lying, to exploit the hypocrisy of the society. Employing a double identity might be seen as lying, and in this section I will investigate how the dualistic theme is revealed through the language and the dialogue, but mostly, in the lying.
We can start analysing the name “E(a)rnest”. Its obvious pun gives a double meaning to both the name and the word because the name is used by Jack to escape of the reality of the countryside and the word means “honesty” that it is the opposite Jack does using this name as his. It happens a similar thing with the name of Bunbury: it can lead to a new verb, ‘bunburying’ or to ‘bunburist’; “now that I know you to be a confirmed Bunburist I naturally want to talk to you about Bunburying” (302) as Algy says. When Lady Bracknell hears that the fictitious Bunbury is dead, that he ‘quite exploded’, Algy uses the word figuratively but Lady Bracknell interprets it literally. Wilde also uses the rhetorical device of inversion for a comic efect: when a character starts to use an expression in one way but ends it in another unexpected way, for example, when Algy says: “I have a business appointment that I am anxious…to miss” (321).
The play then moves to conflicts within one social class. In the relationship between Jack and Algy, Algy is the clear dominator. He makes most of the jokes and forces Jack to tell the truth about his double life. Sometimes they argue about some trivial aspects like food, for example in the first act Algy denies Jack any sandwiches since they are intended for Lady Bracknell, but that does not stop Algy from eating them himself since his aunt comes and he realizes that he ate them all. At the end of act two, Jack morally reproaches Algernon for eating muffins: “I say it’s perfectly heartless your eating muffins at all, under the circumstances”, but he is “beaten” by Algy: “At the present moment I am eating muffins because I am unhappy. Besides, I am particularly fond of muffins” (341), and Algy moreover denies him any of the muffins. Arguing over muffins may seem trivial but here it comes to symbolize Algy’s advantage on the social position.
To see the hypocresy in the play we can look at Lady Bracknell in some scenes. Lady Bracknell is in conflict with Jack and gives many examples of verbal description or distortions of reality. She talks about Jack’s smoking as an ‘occupation’ and that “A man should always have an occupation of some kind. There are too many idle men in London as it is” (308). She approves of something she calls a ‘natural ignorance’ and disapproves of education; “education is radically unsound” (309).
It’s interesting to see what David Parker said about the play:
The Importance of Being Earnest does not tackle problems of moral conduct in the way that most plays do. In it, Wilde expresses a comic vision of the human condition by deliberately distorting actuality and having most of the characters behave as if that vision were all but universal. […] Wilde consciously exploits the concern of farce with human identity. The joke in the title is often thought of as a mock-pompous piece of frivolity, but it is more than that. The play might as justly be named «The Importance of Being.» The whole thing is comically addressed to the problem of recognizing and defining human identity; we are made to see wide significance in Jack’s polite request, «Lady Bracknell, I hate to seem inquisitive, but would you kindly inform me who I am?» (p. 107). The pun on earnest and Ernest merely makes the title more suitably comic. Neither being earnest nor being Ernest is of much help when confidence is lost in the substantiality of human identity. The concern with identity is repeatedly underlined in the text of the play, where statements that seem superficially only to poke fun at upper-class frivolity continually edge the mind toward a contemplation of the insubstantiality of identity. «It isn’t easy to be anything nowadays,» complains Algy in the first act. […] In Wilde’s world truth itself dwindles into insignificance. The characters have a strictly practical attitude to the relationship between statements and actuality, the latter being so elusive. Charged with being named John, Jack declares, «I could deny it if I liked. I could deny anything if I liked» (p. 81). Then he goes on to say that he has never had a brother, which turns out to be untrue; Algy is his brother. Once again the inference is that truth cannot be discovered through the senses and the intellect alone. Jack’s witty lies are more percipient. The comic inversion of truth and untruth is maintained in Jack’s dismay, when he learns that what he had thought to be lies are true. «Gwendolen,» he says, «it is a terrible thing for a man to find out suddenly that all his life he has been speaking nothing but the truth. Can you forgive me?» She can. «There is always hope,» she says, «even for those who are most accurate in their statements» (p. 114)
There are a lot more interesting fragments in his essay but what is important to highlight is that the author chose in a peculiar way all this lies that form the work. This are essential to understand how Wilde uses language to invert some situations and conversations, and how the truth is something relative in this play.