Conclusion.

In this second paper we have seen a lot of reviews and opinions, and maybe now it is a little messy to understand my central idea, so I will summarize it here, in the conclusion.

Chronologically, we have seen a lot of good opinions about the first book due to the novelty, because it was written with the perspective of an autistic boy, one could imagine and feel what the boy felt in each moment thanks to the meticulousness of the details and the way he was telling the story, with all his thoughts, drawings, maps and explanations. The single point of view in the first novel was a very good thing that Mark Haddon used to make the novel original.

Then, with A Spot of Bother, we have seen that the point of view changed from one to four perspectives. And this got some negative criticisms because it was not as easy to follow the story as in the first book, you could not stay for long with one character and understand their thoughts well because Haddon jumped from one to other and that caused difficulties, it was repetitive and without shape, this leaded to lose the intensity of the first book. One of the critiques that I had put in the post related to this second book that compares this two books says that: While Mr. Haddon’s previous book had so many unusual aspects, right down to Christopher’s drawings, maps and equations, his latest is enough like a soap opera to be mistaken for one. So a lot of the critics agree that the second book has lost the most important thing that the first book had, and it is the single and intense point of view of only one character.

With the third and last book it happens the same, and even worse, because in this book it is not only four different perspectives but eight. It is like Haddon went too far with his idea of trying to represent all the characters and not to have any protagonist, we can see that it was not a good idea to write his third novel from eight different perspectives, and even less to jump from one to another sometimes only in a page. People are not used to read things like this, people are used to stay for a while and to read some pages or even chapters about only one character with only their thoughts, not every page one character and completely different perspectives. So this is the main thing criticized in Haddon’s last book.

Also some opinions say that the readers of this 2 last novels expect more after reading The Curious Incident and it is because the things that I have explained above, especially the point of view that has increased from one to eight.

Now I want to show two opinions from reviews that compare the three books, and you will better understand what I mean with this progression that suffered the Haddon’s novels:

One is from a page that is called NPR Books, and the author, Heller McAlpin says that: «Haddon first demonstrated a remarkable ability to fully inhabit another person’s point of view in 2003’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, his quirky murder mystery narrated by a young autistic boy. He followed that with 2006’s A Spot of Bother, a dark comedy in which he alternated between four family members who were driving each other crazy as they careened toward the daughter’s possibly ill-advised second marriage. Unfortunately, by doubling the number of points of view in The Red House, Haddon has so fractured his narrative that it rarely gains momentum and feels as fragmented as its characters.»

And this second one, written by Simon Thomas, that tells that Haddon has gone far away from his strenghts with The Red House : «Curious Incident was (and still is) magnificent, thanks to an exceptionally strong narrative voice. A Spot of Bother was flawed, but still gripping and surprisingly visceral in places – and the characterisation was second to none. In The Red House, despite a couple of strong passages such as Richard’s disastrous run out on the moors, there’s nothing to make this stand out. It’s an ambitious experiment, and perhaps an admirable one; to his credit, at least Mark Haddon is still pushing his craft and trying new things. However, it’s a huge disappointment that in doing so he has moved so far away from his strengths.»

As you can see, this paper has been done from a reader-response analysis because I had focused on the reader’s reactions to the text and we can see that there are plenty of different reader responses to this literary work.

So now, after seeing all the comparisons and opinions we can have our own about Haddon’s literature. I think that it is a little exaggerated to say that he has disappointed people by writing his following books after The Curious Incident because the next books were not as bad as most of the reviewers say, but I think that the point of this «negative» reviews is that Mark decided to write something different, and something that is different not always please everybody. You have to be patient to read his books, that is one thing that is true, and not everybody will like the books, but it is all a matter of taste.

I have really enjoyed doing this paper, it was interesting to find out that the following books were criticized because of the point of view, it was not something that I expected before doing it, so it surprised me, I did not expected the following novels of Haddon to be as they are, and I have learned a lot about him by doing this paper. (I have to admit that this second paper was not as difficult to do as the first, but it is maybe because I have learned more about the right method to do this type of works, I mean, the papers. And also I have to say that I was lucky because the paper has to be done comparing three books, and it is exactly the number of novels that Haddon has written, if I had to do this paper 3 years ago I would have some problems because by then he has not written his last book, so I was really fortunate).

I hope that you have enjoyed reading this paper and also that you have learned something about this author and his books.

Articulo publicado en Sin categoría. Guarda el enlace permanente.

Deja una respuesta

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *