Analysis of the point of view.

 

As Sarah Jaquette said in her work about this book, the most important way that the novel achieves its message that disability is a social construction is through point of view and using form to critique the dominant novel form: the novel is written from Christopher’s perspective, rather than being about Christopher. The story opens with Christopher writing a story—which is the novel itself—about finding his neighbor’s dog murdered by a pitchfork. He writes this murder mystery novel (which is The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time) as an assignment for his special education teacher, Siobhan. That Christopher is in a special education class is the strongest evidence that he has a disability.

 In response to being categorized as «special needs,» Christopher compares himself to the people around him, trying to locate himself in this order of normalcy:

But this is stupid because everyone has learning difficulties because learning to speak French or understanding relativity is difficult and also everyone has special needs, like Father, who has to carry a little packet of artificial sweetening tablets around with him to put in his coffee to stop him from getting fat, or Mrs. Peters, who wears a beige-colored hearing aid, or Siobhan, who has glasses so thick that they give you a headache if you borrow them, and none of these people are Special Needs, even if they have special needs. (43-44)

 Here, Christopher sees his limitations as comparable to wearing glasses. If you struggle to understand quantum mechanics, you have a «learning difficulty.» This passage suggests that it is the need that defines disability, not the person. Disability is relative.

 It is shown how normal Christopher is, and, through Christopher’s perspective, how silly society’s ideas of normalcy are. For example, Christopher’s life goals are perfectly «normal»: he wants to get a degree and a job, earn lots of money, and «get a lady to marry me […] so she can look after me so I can have company» (45). This characterization of a «normal» life trajectory shows that «normal» people are not any different from him, despite the tyranny of normalcy that constantly stigmatizes him. And, in contrast, normates are irrational, unobservant, and mean to animals (100), in Christopher’s estimation. They «leap to the wrong conclusions,» as in detective novels (99), they stupidly make decisions based on intuition rather than logic (65), and, as Christopher reasons, «sometimes people want to be stupid and they do not want to know the truth» (90). «Normal» people are inferior to him. Perhaps normal is not ideal. At times in the novel, we are struck by the thought that this boy is more normal—or, at a minimum, more adjusted and knowledgeable of himself— than the «normal» people in the novel.

 Jay McInerney also talks about Christopher’s point of view in one of his articles written in The New York Times. “Haddon manages to bring us deep inside Christopher’s mind and situates us comfortably within his limited, severely logical point of view, to the extent that we begin to question the common sense and the erratic emotionalism of the normal citizens who surround him, as well as our own intuitions and habits of perception. […] Christopher’s mind is logical and literal in the extreme; early on he suggests that metaphor is a form of lying, pointing out that very few people actually have skeletons in their closets or apples in their eyes. »When I try and make a picture of the phrase in my head it just confuses me because imagining an apple in someone’s eye doesn’t have anything to do with liking someone a lot and it makes you forget what the person was talking about.» Christopher’s inability to tell lies is one of the many reasons he has difficulty engaging in, or understanding, normal social intercourse.”

 The point of view is very important in this novel as we can see in the quotations above, it is important because we can start thinking like the protagonist and we can empathize with him and understand him a little more. The point of view of his mother is very important too, because she sees herself as unable to take care of him, she feels bad because she left them but she can’t do anything, we can see in this quotation that I had compiled in my case study that the fact that she left, and she was unable, made her feel sad and to think that she didn’t do her work as a mother well: “I was not a very good mother, Christopher. Maybe if things had been different, maybe if you’d been differant, I might have been better at it. But that’s just the way things turned out.”(chapter 157).

 To end up this point, Michiko Kakutani, a journalist from The New York Times too, says that: “Christopher’s detective work eventually takes him on a frightening trip to London, a trip that Mr. Haddon makes us experience from the boy’s point of view as a harrowing adventure, as scary as anything in an action thriller. And it also leads to an unraveling of his own family’s past. He discovers a secret that utterly rocks his hermetic world, and he is forced to re-evaluate all that he has taken for granted for so long: a terrifying prospect for someone as anxious as he is about change and the lack of routine.” As we can see, all the reviews and opinions mention the point of view because it is a essencial topic and theme to treat.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Introduction.

Mark Haddon’s 2003 national bestseller, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time is a novel about an average 15-year old boy, Christopher Boone, living in contemporary England. Christopher’s parents are separated, and he is being raised by his father in a middle-class neighborhood in Swindon. Readers are never explicitly made aware of what makes Christopher «not normal,» but his ostensible «disability»—possibly Asperger’s Syndrome, a high functioning form of autism—shapes the narrative.

This book has been a success both between adult and young readers, and also it has been performed in theaters in many occasions so this novel has reached success thanks to his plot that is simple but moving, this prosperity is in a way thanks to the way that the book is written so that the reader can understand how the protagonist perceive the world, and maybe because of the new perspective that they can reach after reading it.

There are a lot of opinions about this book and my purpose is to show the contrast between ones and others, some of them more “scientific” and others subjective due to personal experience(like in the case that we are going to see later of a father of a Asperger’s child and in the case of one of high functioning autistic teenagers that read the book.

I will also talk (briefly) about the point of view in the book that I think that is essential to understand and to feel the book and the story behind it, how the main character’s father suffer and also his mother and how the protagonist feels and conceives the world that surrounds him.

Finally, in the conclusion I will explain the difficulties that I had found doing the paper and the things that I had learnt. So I hope that you will enjoy reading, and also learn something about this fantastic (in my modest opinion) book.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Case study. Practical Criticism.

THE CURIOUS INCIDENT OF THE DOG IN THE NIGHT-TIME.

I’ve chosen ‘The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time’ for my case study. It’s a mystery novel written by Mark Haddon in 2003 and it is about a fifteen years old boy, called Christopher Boone who has the Asperger’s Syndrome so it leads him to have social problems and to have a special behaviour in some situations.

The book starts with Christopher’s discovery of the death of his neighbour’s dog, called Wellington. He wants to know who has killed the dog, and it takes him to start an investigation and to write a book of this event, this research that first seems quite easy to solve, uncovers some events related to his life, for example that the owner of the dog and his father had a romantic affair, and that her mother, who was dead according to his father, is alive and she’s living in London with his neighbour’s ex husband, Mr. Shears. The fact that Christopher discovers that his father lied to him about his mother turns into another discover that is crucial to the solution of the book, and that is that his father killed Wellington after an argument with Mrs. Shears. This event makes Christopher to feel afraid of his father and makes him escape to London in search of his mother. After dealing with some problems he finally finds her and they both return to Swindon, where his father lives and they rebuild their relation.

The theme I want to talk about is the fact that the story is told from the point of view of an autist teenager and how that affects the narration: what he does and how he thinks in some situations, the way he struggles to be independent and the frustration of the people around him when they couldn’t communicate with him, and on the other hand I want to talk about how the story could have changed if the narrator was another teenager who didn’t have this disorder.

To start with, I have to say that Christopher is a boy that has social problems because he is not able to figure out what others think or feel, he cannot empathize with people (he is not able to determine a person’s mood by their facial expressions, he can only do it with the sad and the happy ones) so he doesn’t trust to many people and he get overwhelmed in a lot of moments. He also doesn’t like people to touch him and he is scared of strangers. He has a lot of peculiaritys in his character and he sometimes acts aggressive.
I have a quotation to show his difficulty to know what others feel: “I got Siobhan to draw lots of these faces and then write down next to them exactly what they meant. I kept the piece of paper in my pocket and took it out when I didn’t understand what someone was saying. But it was very difficult to decide which of the diagrams was most like the face they were making because people’s faces move very quickly.” (Chapter 3) and another one to prove how he acts and what happens to him when he gets overhelmed: “I put my hands over my ears and closed my eyes and rolled forward till I was hunched up with my forehead pressed onto the grass. The grass was wet and cold. It was nice.” (Chapter 5).

Nevertheless, he is an intelligent boy as we can see in this quotation: “My name is Christopher John Francis Boone. I know all the countries of the world and their capital cities and every prime number up to 7,057.” (Chapter 3)
He is very good at maths, science, he is interested in astronomy, as you can see in this quotation: “When you look in direction A, at 90° to the disk, you don’t see many stars. But when you look in direction B, you see lots more stars because you are looking into the main body of the galaxy, and because the galaxy is a disk you see a stripe of stars.” (Chapter 13) and he has an accurate memory. His memory allows him to remember an entire event in extraordinary detail, to show this I have another quotation: “It was 1:12 a.m. when Father arrived at the police station. I did not see him until 1:28 a.m. but I knew he was there because I could hear him.” (Chapter 31).
As I went by the story, little by little I understood the way Christopher thinks and his explanations and thoughts helped me to understand how he sees the world.
I think that the author wanted to emphasize the idea that every person has their own view of the world, and to someone some situation can be ridiculous or excessive but for others it is not, for example when Christopher discovers that his father killed the dog and he thinks that he can kill him too, so he becomes afraid of his own dad.

Another thing related to the point of view of the story, is that all the story is told by Christopher’s point of view, but in the chapter 139 and 157 when he finds his mother’s letters she turns as the narrator, we can see and understand her, and why she left them because she saw she felt so frustrated with Christopher and her inability to deal with his behavior, she thought they would be better and happier if she left them. I could see that his mother loves him because she wrote 43 letters during 2 years without getting no response, but she was also very impatient to cope with the reality of Christopher’s condition, when he finally founds her we see that she loves him and she has become more strong-willed but also she has doubts about her ability to take care of him.
Here I have some quotations to prove how she felt when she left and how much she loved Christopher: “I was looking through some old photos last night, which made me sad. Then I found a photo of you playing with the train set we bought for you a couple of Christmas’s ago. And that made me happy because it was one of the really good times we had together.” and another where she explained her flaws at being a mother of him “I was not a very good mother, Christopher. Maybe if things had been different, maybe if you’d been differant, I might have been better at it. But that’s just the way things turned out.”.

I can see an obvious progress through the story with Christopher’s character and determination, he starts beeing a little dependent of his father but then he deals with a lot of things and he does things that make him proud of himself. He talks about his goals for the future and he show a better confidence in himself and he becomes more independent by going alone to London and finding his mother. He is aware of the ways his conditions limits him but he feels more confident because of his recent achievements like solving the mystery of Wellington’s death, acting corageously when he was afraid and finishing his book. He has proven to himself that he can live on his own and he is willing to go to a university and to start a new life, alone with his new puppy Sandy.

I also want to say that the events of the story would be the same if it was told by a normal teenager but the way it would be told it wouldn’t be the same because Christopher focuses on different topics that a common teenager would focus at his age, for example he thinks about prime numbers, constellations and stars because he wants to be an astronaut and about math problems and things related to how he notice the world against what a common teenager at his age would think about , more social things like sports, going out with friends and maybe girls.
What I want to say with this is that despite his condition, he tries so much to do what he wants and that he thinks about his future like any other teenager, maybe he has some problems with controling himself in some situations but he tries to live his life the best he can.

In my opinion I think that sometimes the book gets a little stressing because of the point of view of Christopher, he narrates the facts in a way that makes you feel like him and there were times when I was reading the book and I got nervous and it made me feel overwhelmed in some way, so I think that the author gets what he wanted to (writing the book), he wanted to make the reader feel like Christopher and he reaches this goal. I also think that what the author wanted to show is that Christopher is not “strange” but only different, that there are not “good” and “bad” ways of seeing the world but only different perspectives. Apart from that, the book is okay and it’s easy to read because of the simple language that Christopher uses to write it.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario