‘The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time’ was success, and like it is normal, it had a lot of positive reactions, but as it happens always, there are negative opinions about the book because it can be written for the pleasure of everyone. So now we are going to see first the good and positive criticisms about the novel and then one negative that seemed to me in a way comprehensive. Let’s see.
The San Jose Mercury News said, «Haddon does something audacious here, and he does it superbly. He shows us the way consciousness orders the world, even when the world doesn’t want to be ordered,» adding that «the great achievement of this novel is that it transcends its obvious cleverness. It’s more than an exercise in narrative ingenuity. Filled with humor and pain, it verges on profundity in its examination of those things—customs, habits, language, symbols, daily routines, etc.—that simultaneously unite and separate human beings.»
For Jay McInerney «Christopher’s book seemingly has a nice tidy ending, as he would have wished — horrified as he is of indeterminacy. But this tidiness is an illusion, as the gulf between Christopher and his parents, between Christopher and the rest of us, remains immense and mysterious. And that gulf is ultimately the source of this novel’s haunting impact. Christopher Boone is an unsolved mystery — but he is certainly one of the strangest and most convincing characters in recent fiction.»
Another positive reaction to the book was the one of Charlotte Moore who says that «there is comfort as well as sorrow. Christopher’s innocence makes him vulnerable, but it protects him too. At the end, when order is restored, we see that he is a touchstone for adult behaviour. Those concerned with his welfare have to learn to temper their emotional needs round his autistic inability to compromise. «This will not be a funny book,» says Christopher. «I cannot tell jokes because I do not understand them.» But it is a funny book, as well as a sad one. Christopher’s compulsive noting of mundane facts provides comedy reminiscent of the best of Adrian Mole, especially in his dealings with the police and his special-needs classmates. And Haddon’s inclusion of diagrams, timetables, maps, even maths problems, extends the normal scope of novel-writing and demonstrates the rich idiosyncrasies of the autistic brain. The Curious Incident is published simultaneously for adults and older children; despite its clarity and simplicity, it operates on several levels. I’d love to know what a reader with Asperger’s thinks of this book. I think it’s brilliant.»
Michiko Kakutani opines that «in recounting these developments in a fractured, digression-filled narrative, Christopher emerges as a wonderfully vivid individual. He never for a moment feels like a generic teenager or a composite portrait of someone with Asperger’s syndrome (the form of autism that he presumably suffers from). At the same time, Mr. Haddon writes with such sympathy, such understanding of Christopher’s interior life, that he makes all his obsessions and needs into a mirror of our own cravings for safety and order, while turning Christopher’s »detective story» into a bildungsroman that’s not about finding solutions and proofs but about coming to terms with the disorder and betrayals of grown-up life.»
After all this reviewer’s opinions and articles, I want to show you one that I have found from an article of a journalist who gave the book to a boy who had the syndrome, and this is the reaction: «I gave the book to a high functioning autistic teenager. My observation was that it was read with interest, and on more than one occasion, despite the fact that it is a story about people, rather than the usual literary choice of science fiction or a manual. Apparently Christopher’s thought processes and approach to life were entirely believable apart from the fact that on one page, – “there is an error. I do not know about all autistic people but I do know about myself and I would say that an autistic person would not say that they do not care about details, as I am very good at details. It is approximation that is difficult.” This being the only criticism, following my request for a formal review, I would take it that Christopher’s character is equally believable to an autist. […] Anyone working with people, especially teens and preteens, with pervasive developmental disorders, and enjoying it, will also enjoy this book, as it is so familiarly and delightfully autistic. Those who have little experience with autists will learn a lot. I would highly recommend this to all professionals and parents who have an interest in this area. This story provides a wealth of information in an informative and yet informal fashion. Most of all – it is a good read!»
So after seeing all this positive opinions, here I have some that are not as positive as the ones above. This are the Texas Comunity reactions:
The novel was selected as a recommended book for the 2006 Galveston Reads program, a literacy encouragement program in Galveston County, Texas. Friendswood, Texas, Mayor Kimball Brizendine issued a proclamation declaring January 31 «Galveston County Reads Day» and encouraging «all citizens, teens to seniors» to read the novel. Five days later, he retracted the statement, declaring that it was «not [his] intention to endorse this readership [sic] for our younger readers.» The journal American Libraries reported, «City Council member Chris Peden went a step further, asserting to the January 28 Galveston County Daily News that while he hadn’t read Curious Incident in its entirety, he had noted that the ‘F word’ appeared on page four and that ‘later in the book, the [lead character] says there is no God and there is no life after death. Clearly, these are not ideas we should promote to kids».
In August, 2007, some parents in Bryan, Texas, «were appalled to see what their kids were reading» and protested the inclusion of the book in high school libraries, with one parent claiming that Curious Incident and another book (Catalyst by Laurie Halse Anderson) were «unsuitable for not just some but all high school students».
To finish this post, I have the negative opinion that I have spoken about before, and it is written by a father of an autist boy who has the syndrome.
«Boone describes himself as «a mathematician with some behavioural difficulties,» but despite this stylistic obfuscation, we’re not left to guess at his diagnosis. Early book jackets made explicitly clear that he has Asperger’s syndrome. […] Asperger’s tends to be a relatively mild form of autistic spectrum disorder. Most aspies are «high-functioning.» They don’t refuse to go to school if they spy a yellow car, or curl up into a whimpering ball on a train because there are too many people around, as Boone does in Curious Incident. Indeed, if Christopher John Francis Boone has Asperger’s, as we’ve been led to believe, he has one of the most extreme forms of the disorder ever recorded.
He strengthen his statement saying that the only opinion that was put in a journal from an autist point of view was a positive one, but he had found that the majority of the people who suffered from the syndrome, opined completely different things:
««Stereotyped, inaccurate, horribly offensive… this isn’t how it is.» «Haddon does not understand Asperger.» «Stereotypical view of an autistic child.» «I find it hard to believe that Mark Haddon is an autism expert, because Christopher Boone isn’t like any other child with Asperger’s that I’ve ever met.» «A major disservice to the Autistic Community.» «An excellent portrayal of autism…NOT!»
The aspie reviewers, as it happens, were onto something. Haddon, by his own admission, is clueless about Asperger’s. «I know very little about the subject,» he confessed on his website, in an blog posted on July 16, 2009.»
He ends saying that he doesn’t «begrudge Haddon his freedom of speech, or his ability to make a living as a man of letters. He can write about whatever he pleases. What I find objectionable is that he seems unaware of — or, worse, indifferent toward — the fact that he has made both his name and his fortune exploiting the Asperger’s community, my son included.» and also that «Haddon did write an Asperger’s character, he did take advantage of the words «Asperger’s Syndrome» in his marketing campaign, and knowingly or not, he did create a negative stereotype. And if he felt anything but indifference toward this literary exploitation after the fact, he would not have used the same narrator-with-relatively-rare-psychological-disorder gimmick in his follow-up novel, as he did with 2006’s A Spot of Bother, replacing Asperger’s with hypochrondria. In any case, the damage is done. Christopher John Francis Boone is to Asperger’s what Raymond Babbitt is to autism. And aspies everywhere — including my son — must now live with it.»
So as we can see by all this opinions, there are plenty of good ones, but there are also negative ones that are not pleased with the book and that think that the author did not do a good work using the Asperger’s Syndrome to write a book that finally became a bestseller.