The Dungeon by Samuel Taylor Coleridge.

THE DUNGEON – S. T. COLERIDGE.

And this place our forefathers made for man!
This is the process of our love and wisdom,
To each poor brother who offends against us –
Most innocent, perhaps -and what if guilty?
Is this the only cure? Merciful God!
Each pore and natural outlet shrivelled up
By Ignorance and parching Poverty,
His energies roll back upon his heart,
And stagnate and corrupt; till changed to poison,
They break out on him, like a loathsome plague-spot;
Then we call in our pampered mountebanks –
And this is their best cure! uncomforted
And friendless solitude, groaning and tears,
And savage faces, at the clanking hour,
Seen through the steam and vapours of his dungeon,
By the lamp’s dismal twilgiht! So he lies
Circled with evil, till his very soul
Unmoulds its essence, hopelessly deformed
By sights of ever more deformity!

With other ministrations thou, O Nature!
Healest thy wandering and distempered child:
Thou pourest on him thy soft influences,
Thy sunny hues, fair forms, and breathing sweets,
Thy melodies of woods, and winds, and waters,
Till he relent, and can no more endure
To be a jarring and a dissonant thing
Amid this general dance and minstrelsy;
But, bursting into tears, wins back his way,
His angry spirit healed and harmonized
By the benignant touch of Love and Beauty.

I have chosen ‘The Dungeon’ by Samuel Taylor Coleridge because I think that it is a curious poem that attracted my attention from the very first moment while I was reading some poems trying to choose one for my presentation and analysis. I liked a lot this one because it is not difficult to understand and it gives you a new perspective of what a cell could be to a prisoner and the effects that it could bring to him or her. So now I will analize the poem and try you to understand it and like it as much as I did.

In the first stanza Coleridge describes the spiritually destroying effect of long-term imprisonment on the human being. He considers that a dungeon doesn’t reformm a criminal but rather cause a permanent harm on him or her.

The symbolism of the 1st stanza is negative, dark and self destroying. The author wants to show the injury that a prison can make to a criminal and it is shown in this fragment: «his energies roll back upon his heart, and stagnate and corrupt; till changed to poison, they break out on him, like a loathsome plague-spot», as we can see there is a lot of negative connotation.

His emotions about the misery of this prison and how it must have felt to experience it are made clear when he mentions this verse: «unconforted and friendless solitude, groaning and tears and savage faces, at the clanking hour…»

The last 2 lines of the first verse contrast with the second line of verse 2: «deformed» and «deformity» in front of «healest». The author shows that the dungeon deforms the sould and unmoulds the essence of the «victim» that in this case is the criminal.

On the other hand, in the second stanza, Coleridge thinks of Nature as a healing by the introduction of «soft influences». This second verse is much more positive and bright than the first. «Sunny hues» now replace «dismal twilight».

The first verse gives the reader the vision of an enclosed cell from which there is no escape, verse two gives the vision of freedom and nature.

Coleridge gives the nature the power of healing that the criminal stops being a jarring and dissonant thing and become a healed and harmonized man.

The underlying idea is that the inner world of human behaviour is influenced by the physical surroundings of the body. To conclude I have to say that there is a big difference between the vocabulary in the two verses, in the first very negative and dark and in the second bright and inspiring.

Here I attach the Prezi presentation I did to expose it, where you can hear the poem and see the differences between one verse and the other thanks to the different colours that I have used or if you prefer to go directly to hear the poem enter here.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Bibliography, works cited.

APPEL, Felicia. «Victorian Ideals: The Influence of Society’s Ideals on Victorian Relationships». Mc Kendree University. 2011. Web. 24 March, 2015. <http://www.mckendree.edu/academics/scholars/issue18/appell.htm>

FRIDELL, Sara. «Dualism in Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest». Goteborgs Universitet. Web. 24 March, 2015. <https://gupea.ub.gu.se/bitstream/2077/36471/1/gupea_2077_36471_1.pdf>

HOLLANDER, John. «Melodious Guile. Fictive Pattern in Poetic Language». Yale University Press. 1988. Web. 24 march, 2015 <http://books.google.es/books/yup?vid=ISBN9780300049046&redir_esc=y>

HUGHES, Kathryn. «Gender roles in the 19th century». The British Library. Web. 25 March, 2015. <http://www.bl.uk/romantics-and-victorians/articles/gender-roles-in-the-19th-century#>

J JORDAN, Robert. «Satire and Fantasy in Wilde’s ‘The Importance of Being Earnest». Web. PDF format. 24 March, 2015.

MLOCEK, Weronika. «Case study: The Importance of Being Earnest». Web. 21 March. 2015. <http://wem.blogs.uv.es/2015/03/21/case-study-introduction-to-english-literature/>

OSSA, Michelle. «In what ways is Oscar Wilde mocking Victorian society?». Enotes. Web. 24 march. 2015 <http://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-ways-oscar-wilde-mocking-victorian-society-251682>

PARKER, David. «Oscar Wilde’s Great Farce The Importance of Being Earnest » University of Malaya. 2003. Web. 24 March, 2015. <http://bahamateach.yolasite.com/resources/Oscar%20Wilde’s%20Great%20Farce.pdf>

PETRIE, Charles. “Victorian Women Expected to Be Idle and Ignorant.” Victorian England. Ed. Clarice Swisher. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, Inc., 2000. 178-87.

SCHLEGEL, MELISSA. «Structuralist Criticism of Oscar Wilde’s The Importance of Being Earnest.» Dr. Marck, Literature 420. 3 March 2011. Web. DOC format. 24 de marzo, 2015.

WALLACE, Sarah. «The Importance of Being Subversive». ARTicles vol.4 i.bc. Web. 25 March, 2015. <http://americanrepertorytheater.org/inside/articles/articles-vol4-ibc-importance-being-subversive>

«Marriage». The Birmingham Repertory Theatre. Web. 25 March, 2015. <http://www.birmingham-rep.co.uk/participate/resource-packs/the-importance-of-being-earnest/themes>

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women_in_the_Victorian_era > Web. 23 March, 2015.

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Importance_of_Being_Earnest> Web. 23 March, 2015.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Conclusion.

On the one hand, the institution of marriage and family life is mocked foremost by Algy: “If I get married, I’ll certainly try to forget the fact” (297), but yet they all try to become married. Marriage at that time was, as I said before many times, seen as a business, an agreement between families to improve their mutual situation and to mantain the costumes and the name. Even that it has almost changed and nowadays marriage is intended to be because of the love of a couple, there are still cases that marriage is because of the convenience.

On the other hand, despite the fact that all the characters have secret lives and constantly lie, they all claim to be speakers of truth. The characters not only state truths expressing their morality, they also emphasize truthfulness, which runs as a theme through the play. Algy is the first to claim to be a speaker of truth when accused of talking nonsense in act one: “It isn’t [nonsense]. It is a great truth” (298).

As we can see, the theme of truthfulness illuminates the contrasted concept of lying; the characters often lie when they claim to speak the truth, but they also call attention to the fact that style and credulity is more important than actually speaking the truth. In the end of the play, the lies are revealed as the truths, which suggest a complementary relation between the two concepts.

It became obvious that some of the characters were leading a double life and that they were lying about it. They claimed to be speakers of truth and they used assertive language to conceal their lies. The frequent use of lies and language with double meanings in the play suggests that there is duplicity in lying and that the truth has two sides, just like the characters in the play are dual and have two sides.

While the title The Importance of Being Earnest implies that honesty is important, most of the characters are perpetually dishonest. Jack and Algernon lie regularly in order to avoid social obligations and pursue pleasure. Over the course of the play, the characters create increasingly complicated lies in order to fill in the holes of their previous lies. At the end of the second act, however, their web of lies comes unwoven around them. Despite the ultimate failure of their deceit, neither man appears to regret his dishonesty. In the end, it is more important to be Ernest than earnest.

Maybe what Wilde wanted to say to us was that it doesn’t exist only a unique «myself» but maybe it’s a union of the good and the bad things, and sometimes that is needed for a person to be whole and complete, because we as human beings we are complex and with a lot of diversities that make our identity and personality to be unique and excepcional.

I have to conclude saying that this paper was not easy to do because of the amount of information that was not useful to me, so I had to search a lot to find quality information that I could use to do this paper. It was not easy but it worth the time I spent searching because now I have read a lot of opinions and I have got many skills to do my next academic work.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Lies through language.

As Sara Fridell says and I add, Wilde used double identity as well as a dualistic theme in the play, revealed in the language and in the strategies of lying, to exploit the hypocrisy of the society. Employing a double identity might be seen as lying, and in this section I will investigate how the dualistic theme is revealed through the language and the dialogue, but mostly, in the lying.

We can start analysing the name “E(a)rnest”. Its obvious pun gives a double meaning to both the name and the word because the name is used by Jack to escape of the reality of the countryside and the word means “honesty” that it is the opposite Jack does using this name as his. It happens a similar thing with the name of Bunbury: it can lead to a new verb, ‘bunburying’ or to ‘bunburist’; “now that I know you to be a confirmed Bunburist I naturally want to talk to you about Bunburying” (302) as Algy says. When Lady Bracknell hears that the fictitious Bunbury is dead, that he ‘quite exploded’, Algy uses the word figuratively but Lady Bracknell interprets it literally. Wilde also uses the rhetorical device of inversion for a comic efect: when a character starts to use an expression in one way but ends it in another unexpected way, for example, when Algy says: “I have a business appointment that I am anxious…to miss” (321).

 The play then moves to conflicts within one social class. In the relationship between Jack and Algy, Algy is the clear dominator. He makes most of the jokes and forces Jack to tell the truth about his double life. Sometimes they argue about some trivial aspects like food, for example in the first act Algy denies Jack any sandwiches since they are intended for Lady Bracknell, but that does not stop Algy from eating them himself since his aunt comes and he realizes that he ate them all. At the end of act two, Jack morally reproaches Algernon for eating muffins: “I say it’s perfectly heartless your eating muffins at all, under the circumstances”, but he is “beaten” by Algy: “At the present moment I am eating muffins because I am unhappy. Besides, I am particularly fond of muffins” (341), and Algy moreover denies him any of the muffins. Arguing over muffins may seem trivial but here it comes to symbolize Algy’s advantage on the social position.

 To see the hypocresy in the play we can look at Lady Bracknell in some scenes. Lady Bracknell is in conflict with Jack and gives many examples of verbal description or distortions of reality. She talks about Jack’s smoking as an ‘occupation’ and that “A man should always have an occupation of some kind. There are too many idle men in London as it is” (308). She approves of something she calls a ‘natural ignorance’ and disapproves of education; “education is radically unsound” (309).

It’s interesting to see what David Parker said about the play:

The Importance of Being Earnest does not tackle problems of moral conduct in the way that most plays do. In it, Wilde expresses a comic vision of the human condition by deliberately distorting actuality and having most of the characters behave as if that vision were all but universal. […] Wilde consciously exploits the concern of farce with human identity. The joke in the title is often thought of as a mock-pompous piece of frivolity, but it is more than that. The play might as justly be named «The Importance of Being.» The whole thing is comically addressed to the problem of recognizing and defining human identity; we are made to see wide significance in Jack’s polite request, «Lady Bracknell, I hate to seem inquisitive, but would you kindly inform me who I am?» (p. 107). The pun on earnest and Ernest merely makes the title more suitably comic. Neither being earnest nor being Ernest is of much help when confidence is lost in the substantiality of human identity. The concern with identity is repeatedly underlined in the text of the play, where statements that seem superficially only to poke fun at upper-class frivolity continually edge the mind toward a contemplation of the insubstantiality of identity. «It isn’t easy to be anything nowadays,» complains Algy in the first act. […] In Wilde’s world truth itself dwindles into insignificance. The characters have a strictly practical attitude to the relationship between statements and actuality, the latter being so elusive. Charged with being named John, Jack declares, «I could deny it if I liked. I could deny anything if I liked» (p. 81). Then he goes on to say that he has never had a brother, which turns out to be untrue; Algy is his brother. Once again the inference is that truth cannot be discovered through the senses and the intellect alone. Jack’s witty lies are more percipient. The comic inversion of truth and untruth is maintained in Jack’s dismay, when he learns that what he had thought to be lies are true. «Gwendolen,» he says, «it is a terrible thing for a man to find out suddenly that all his life he has been speaking nothing but the truth. Can you forgive me?» She can. «There is always hope,» she says, «even for those who are most accurate in their statements» (p. 114)

 

There are a lot more interesting fragments in his essay but what is important to highlight is that the author chose in a peculiar way all this lies that form the work. This are essential to understand how Wilde uses language to invert some situations and conversations, and how the truth is something relative in this play.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Triviality of marriage.

 The status of women in the Victorian era was not as fair as it is nowadays: women did not have suffrage rights, the right to sue, or the right to own property, women couldn’t decide by themselves completely because they were subordinated first to their father and then when their father decided what man was better to his dauther’s future, they passed to be subordinated to their husbands. The ideal Victorian women was pure, chaste, refined, and modest. This ideal was supported by manners.

 Victorian men also expected women to possess feminine qualities like innocence; otherwise, they would not be of marriage potential. In Charles Petrie’s article, “Victorian Women Expected to be Idle and Ignorant,” he explains exactly what the Victorian man was looking for:

Innocence was what he demanded from the girls of his class, and they must not only be innocent but also give the outward impression of being innocent. White muslin, typical of virginal purity, clothes many a heroine, with delicate shades of blue and pink next in popularity. The stamp of masculine approval was placed upon ignorance of the world, meekness, lack of opinions, general helplessness and weakness; in short, recognition of female inferiority to the male (Petrie 184).

 In Wilde’s play, he comically satirizes the name “Earnest,” through the representation of two dishonest men whom the women fantasize as being ideal men worthy of marriage. These two men claim to live up to the Victorian ideals, but then live another life outside of the community to escape the society’s pressures and responsabilities. From now on, in the play, the men fall under the pressure of women and Victorian ideals rather than staying true to their identity and personalities.

 The pressure from the Victorian society influences the way Cecily and Gwendolyn view men. They dream of the perfect man to take them as their wife, and they believe it is the only way to satisfy the dream of marriage that Victorian women dream of since infancy, according to Petrie (Petrie 180). As they dream of the perfect man, Gwendolyn and Cecily have adopted the Victorian concept of the perfect man to shape their expectations of their potential husbands. Alan Ackerman argues the dangers in ideals, such as the ideal of a name: “‘The false ideal[s] of our time’ are shown to be disastrous in nearly every one of Wilde’s plays. ‘Ideals are dangerous things,’”(Ackerman 142). While the ideal of a name may not cause physical danger, it may affect a couple’s relationship emotionally because of the temptations to live up to the expectations of the partner, so that maybe Jack and Algernon, when the ladies of the play finally know them completely they were not what Cecily and Gwendolyn expected, maybe (surely) they were not the perfect man that they wanted to have as a husband.

 It is known that a young girl was not expected to focus too obviously on finding a husband. Being ‘forward’ in the company of men suggested a worrying sexual appetite. Women were assumed to desire marriage because it allowed them to become mothers rather than to pursue sexual or emotional satisfaction. One doctor, William Acton, famously declared that ‘The majority of women (happily for them) are not very much troubled with sexual feeling of any kind’.

Girls usually married in their early to mid-20s. Typically, the husband would be five years older. Not only did this reinforce the ‘natural’ hierarchy between the sexes, but it also made sound financial sense. A young man needed to be able to show that he earned enough money to support a wife and any future children before the girl’s father would give his permission. Some unfortunate couples were obliged to endure an engagement lasting decades before they could afford to marry.

 Below they are speaking about the permission of the girl’s father to let some man marry their daugther, but in this play, when Jack asks Gwendolen to marry him, it is not her father who have to accept the petition but her mother, Lady Bracknell. It’s another, we can call it, irony that Wilde uses to criticize the Victorian society, but this theme is going to be discussed in the next section.

 As we can see, marriage was seen as a business, to keep the family’s name or to improve some family’s statement. Women married for security. Even that it is seen as that during the Victorian era, there are different opinions in the play: Algernon has a very cynical view of marriage until he meets (and falls in love with) Cecily; Jack is the romantic through out the entire play up until the end – Gwendolen and Cecily are obsessed with marrying a man with the name of Earnest so that is not a real love but in a way it’s an obsession and Lady Bracknell thinks that marriage is a business.

 The fact that both women have fixated on the importance of marrying someone called Ernest than other things like the feelings or anything else demonstrates Wilde’s attitude to the superficiality of Victorian morals around marriage. This is highlighted by the use of the joke around the name Ernest, when the two men pretending to be called Ernest are not being earnest, what means serious, sincere, but the opposite and it’s here where we can see the hypocrisy of the society that Wilde criticizes.

 Finally it is important to consider that Wilde introduces through the characters marriage as something without importance, for some it is something about interests, but for the main characters, marriage has the same importance as choosing what they are going to eat(sometimes in the play food has even more importance than marriage, like the significance they give to the cucumber sandwiches and to sugar and cake) so for them to marry with someone is something that one can decide from one day to another, and that’s why the play is so trivial, in a way that makes the play to be hypocritical because of the character’s way of doing and speaking, and because of the importance they give to some things and not to other.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Introduction.

The Importance of Being Earnest is a play written by Oscar Wilde, in which he treats in a trivial way serious themes like marriage and it becomes a satire of the Victorian times.

I’ve chosen this book to do my 1st paper because I like the way Wilde criticizes the society and the way he expresses all that information in a way that everyone can laugh at some situations that not always could happen in real life. I also have chosen this book because of the way marriage is treated, I think that it is interesting and especially from the point of view of the Victorian society.

As we will see later, contemporary reviews all praised the play’s humour, though some were cautious about its explicit lack of social messages, while others foresaw the modern consensus that it was the culmination of Wilde’s artistic career so far and they see how Wilde criticized the society in which he lived, so they play was not lacked of message.

Firstly I will talk about marriage in the Victorian Era and how it is shown in the play, and also about what marriage is for every different character, we will see that for some of them marriage is like a business and for others it is all about love. It is important to say that marriage appears as something trivial and they don’t give a lot of attention to it, in the play it is shown that sometimes you don’t need to completely know the person you are marrying.

Then I am going to focus on the presence of irony and lies in the work and on how hypocritical are the characters in a lot of situations, Wilde does a criticism of the society in that times and we will see briefly how it appears in the play.

Finally I will present my conclusion where I will talk about my opinion and about what were the feelings and impressions doing the paper, what dificulties I had found doing it and obviously to what conclusion I had arrived after doing all this research.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Case study. Introduction to English Literature.

THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING EARNEST.

‘The Importance of Being Earnest’ is a play written by Oscar Wilde in 1895. It is a social comedy of manners that talks about the seriousness and customs of Victorian society. In this play Wilde reflects the vices and virtues of the society in an exaggerated way to create a funny and critical entertainment. The play is divided in 3 acts and each one happens in a different place in the Victorian times in Great Britain.

Wilde plays with the triviality of some themes like lies and marriage, so this are going to be my main ideas.

To start with I have to say that the two main characters Algernon Moncrieff and Jack Worthing have another fictional life to escape of their problems and responsibilities.
The first one, Algernon, has invented a chronic invalid named Bunbury and he sometimes goes to “see” and take care of him, to prove this I have a quotation where Algernon talks about it: “I have invented an invaluable permanent invalid called Bunbury, in order that I may be able to go down into the country whenever I choose. Bunbury is perfectly invaluable.” (First act); the second one, Jack, takes his lies to another level, he has invented Ernest. In the country where he lives he’s a respectable young man, a major landowner and the pillar of the community, and he says that he has a younger brother that is very irresponsible and often gets into trouble, so when he gets tired of being in the country he has an excuse for disappearing and he goes to the city to “help” his little brother, Ernest. There in the city, in London, he is known as Ernest, he falls in love with Gwendolen and finally he has to tell her the truth. To talk about Jack’s second life I have another quotation where is shown a fragment of the conversation between Algernon and Jack:

 

“Algernon. Besides, your name isn’t Jack at all; it is Ernest.

Jack. It isn’t Ernest; it’s Jack.

Algernon. You have always told me it was Ernest. I have introduced you to everyone as Ernest. You answer to the name of Ernest. You look as if your name was Ernest. You are the most ernest-looking person I ever saw in my life. It is perfectly absurd your saying that your name isn’t Ernest.

Jack. Well, my name is Ernest in town and Jack in the country.” (1st act)
This idea of creating an alternative life to escape from their own lives I have connected it with the Romantics that also did that to evade themselves of what surrounds them and the idea of creating another world, so I think that lies has an important role in this play, Wilde has put them in a way that it becomes a satire. All the play is about lies and not only about the alternative life that the two main characters have but also about others, so I have a quotation to show it: “My dear fellow, the truth isn’t quite the sort of thing one tells to a nice, sweet, refined girl. What extraordinary ideas you have about the way to behave to a woman!” told by Jack Worthing in the 1st act.

 

On the other hand the play also reflects the triviality of marriage.
During all the play they deal with this theme. Since the first moment it is the subject of the conversations and in a way it is the matter of the play. It is Jack who wants to marry Gwendolen because they are in love, and even that Algernon first criticizes marriage as “somewhat lax”, something careless, he finally wants to marry Cecilly because he falls in love with her and here I have the quotation of the very first talk between Algernon and Lane:

 

“Algernon. Is marriage so demoralising?

Lane. I believe it is a very pleasant state, sir. I have had very little experience of myself up to the present. I have only been married once.” (1st act)

 

We can see that for some, marriage is something without real importance, it is something that they do without thinking straight and without getting to know completely the other person they are marring, like Cecily and Algernon do in the play.
On the other hand, for others, marriage is like a business, it is something done only for interests; like in the case of Lady Bracknell that only allows Gwendolen to get married to a man that has a good fortune, resources and possessions, and that is why she does an interview to Jack when they tell her that they want to get married and then she refuses to allow the marriage because she finds that he has not known his parents because they left him in a train station. This quotation is about the interview that Lady Bracknell does to Jack, she goes straight to the subject and she asks him what she wants to know:

 

“Lady Bracknell. What is your income?

Jack. Between seven and eight thousand a year.

Lady Bracknell. (Makes a note in her book.) In land, or in investments?

Jack. In investments, chiefly.” (1st act)

 

Here I have a quote to show how for Algernon at first the proposal of Jack was like a business, and he thought that marriage is not romantic, only love is, but not marriage:

 

“Jack. I am in love with Gwendolen. I have come up to town expressly to propose to her.

Algernon. I thought you had come up for pleasure? … I call that business.

Jack. How utterly unromantic you are!

Algernon. I really don’t see anything romantic in proposing. It is very romantic to be in love. But there is nothing romantic about a definite proposal.” (1st act)
I think that maybe Cecily’s and Algernon’s behavior is a little bit exaggerated, but it is not that exaggerated in Lady Bracknell’s case because in that period marriage was like that because most of the people had this kind of thoughts regarding to marriage, and even I can tell that it still happens nowadays in some cases.
I disliked the relationship between Algernon and Cecily because it seemed to me very strange. She has imagined that she was engaged with Ernest (who firstly she thought it was Jack’s brother) even before she met him, and when Algernon presented himself as Ernest she was so happy to finally know him personally and not only in her mind. I think that it’s ridiculous how she can do that, I mean, I can’t imagine that she can fall in love with someone that she had only imagined in her mind, I don’t know how she could accept to marry a man she doesn’t even know, and how they fall in love so quickly, it is not possible, I know that love at first sight can happen, but it’s very strange. Another quote to show how exaggerated they were is here:

 

“Algernon. Oh, I don’t care about Jack. I don’t care for anybody in the whole world but you. I love you, Cecily. You will marry me, won’t you?

Cecily. You silly boy! Of course. Why, we have been engaged for the last three months.” (2nd act)

 

To conclude I have to emphasize that Wilde wrote this play to make the audience think a little about the vices and virtues of the society and to make them have a good time in theatre, so he tries to introduce his topics gracefully and with softness. I consider that for Wilde it was very important to criticize the matters that were discussed at his times and to make people to be aware about this, and in some cases maybe to make them change their mentality. I have to say that I liked the play because it was easy to understand and it was written with an easy language so I enjoyed a lot reading it.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Bibliography.

JAQUETTE RAY, Sarah. «Normalcy, Knowledge, and Nature in Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time» Disability Studies Quarterly. 2013. Web. 18 March 2015. <http://dsq-sds.org/article/view/3233/3263>

KAKUTANI, Michiko. «BOOKS OF THE TIMES; Math and Physics? A Cinch. People? Incomprehensible.» The New York Times. 13 June, 2003. Web. 18 March, 2015. <http://www.nytimes.com/2003/06/13/books/books-of-the-times-math-and-physics-a-cinch-people-incomprehensible.html>

MARSTON WILLIAM, Jennifer. «Against the Rhetoric of Sadness: Theory of Mind and the Writing Process in The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time» Psy Art Journal. 10 July, 2012. Web. 18 March, 2015. <http://www.psyartjournal.com/article/show/marston_william-against_the_rhetoric_of_sadness_theory_o>

MCINERNEY, Jay. «The Remains of the Dog». The New York Times. 15 June, 2003. Web. 18 March, 2015. <http://www.nytimes.com/2003/06/15/books/the-remains-of-the-dog.html>

MLOCEK, Weronika. «Case study: The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time» Web. 14 March, 2015. <http://wem.blogs.uv.es/2015/03/14/case-study-practical-criticism/>

MOORE, Charlotte. «Just the facts, ma’am» The guardian. 23 May, 2003. Web. 18 March, 2015. <http://www.theguardian.com/books/2003/may/24/booksforchildrenandteenagers.bookerprize2003>

MOSS, Pippa. «Anotations, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time» PMC US National Library of Medicine National Institutes of Health. 14 May, 2005. Web. 18 March, 2015. <http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2542939/>

OLEAR, Greg. «When Popular Novels Perpetuate Negative Stereotypes: Mark Haddon, Asperger’s and Irresponsible Fiction» Huffpost Books. 18 November, 2011. Web. 19 March, 2015. <http://www.huffingtonpost.com/greg-olear/curious-incident-dog-night-time_b_1099692.html>

SARVAS, Mark. Review of ‘The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time’. The modern word. 27 January 2004. Web. 19 March, 2015. <http://www.themodernword.com/reviews/haddon.html>

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Curious_Incident_of_the_Dog_in_the_Night-Time>

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Conclusion.

As we have already seen, this book has been a success since it has been published, there are a lot of good opinions but also some that are not as positive. Most of the critics agree quite well regarding to the fact that the book has been written in a good way so that everyone can understand a little more about the world that surrounds the protagonist and in general terms all of them agree with the whole objective of the book

What is more important in this book is the point of view, thanks to the first person that it is written, we have an access to Christopher’s brain and we can understand how he sees the world. It is obvious that the story would have been different if it were told in the third person because we would not have empathized the way we do when reading the book: this makes us open our minds to the possibility of seeing the world through a different perspective and to rethink about if there is only our own perception the one that is valid and that there are more than one, with the same validity.

This paper has been done from a reader-response analysis because I had focused on the reader’s reactions to the text and we can see that there are plenty of different reader responses to this literary work. I have to admit that it was not easy to search good and valid reviews because of the amount of theatre reviews and not of the book, but I have learnt new research skills that will be useful for the future. As a reader, I have enjoyed a lot this book because when I was reading I completely understood the point of view of the main character so I think that even that the author was not a professional of this disease,  he had done a good work because he made me feel like Christopher in specific situations reading the book and I am sure that I was not the only one that had empathised with the protagonist.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario

Criticism of the novel.

‘The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time’ was success, and like it is normal, it had a lot of positive reactions, but as it happens always, there are negative opinions about the book because it can be written for the pleasure of everyone. So now we are going to see first the good and positive criticisms about the novel and then one negative that seemed to me in a way comprehensive. Let’s see.

The San Jose Mercury News said, «Haddon does something audacious here, and he does it superbly. He shows us the way consciousness orders the world, even when the world doesn’t want to be ordered,» adding that «the great achievement of this novel is that it transcends its obvious cleverness. It’s more than an exercise in narrative ingenuity. Filled with humor and pain, it verges on profundity in its examination of those things—customs, habits, language, symbols, daily routines, etc.—that simultaneously unite and separate human beings.»

For Jay McInerney «Christopher’s book seemingly has a nice tidy ending, as he would have wished — horrified as he is of indeterminacy. But this tidiness is an illusion, as the gulf between Christopher and his parents, between Christopher and the rest of us, remains immense and mysterious. And that gulf is ultimately the source of this novel’s haunting impact. Christopher Boone is an unsolved mystery — but he is certainly one of the strangest and most convincing characters in recent fiction.»

Another positive reaction to the book was the one of Charlotte Moore who says that «there is comfort as well as sorrow. Christopher’s innocence makes him vulnerable, but it protects him too. At the end, when order is restored, we see that he is a touchstone for adult behaviour. Those concerned with his welfare have to learn to temper their emotional needs round his autistic inability to compromise. «This will not be a funny book,» says Christopher. «I cannot tell jokes because I do not understand them.» But it is a funny book, as well as a sad one. Christopher’s compulsive noting of mundane facts provides comedy reminiscent of the best of Adrian Mole, especially in his dealings with the police and his special-needs classmates. And Haddon’s inclusion of diagrams, timetables, maps, even maths problems, extends the normal scope of novel-writing and demonstrates the rich idiosyncrasies of the autistic brain. The Curious Incident is published simultaneously for adults and older children; despite its clarity and simplicity, it operates on several levels. I’d love to know what a reader with Asperger’s thinks of this book. I think it’s brilliant.»

Michiko Kakutani opines that «in recounting these developments in a fractured, digression-filled narrative, Christopher emerges as a wonderfully vivid individual. He never for a moment feels like a generic teenager or a composite portrait of someone with Asperger’s syndrome (the form of autism that he presumably suffers from). At the same time, Mr. Haddon writes with such sympathy, such understanding of Christopher’s interior life, that he makes all his obsessions and needs into a mirror of our own cravings for safety and order, while turning Christopher’s »detective story» into a bildungsroman that’s not about finding solutions and proofs but about coming to terms with the disorder and betrayals of grown-up life.»

After all this reviewer’s opinions and articles, I want to show you one that I have found from an article of a journalist who gave the book to a boy who had the syndrome, and this is the reaction: «I gave the book to a high functioning autistic teenager. My observation was that it was read with interest, and on more than one occasion, despite the fact that it is a story about people, rather than the usual literary choice of science fiction or a manual. Apparently Christopher’s thought processes and approach to life were entirely believable apart from the fact that on one page, – “there is an error. I do not know about all autistic people but I do know about myself and I would say that an autistic person would not say that they do not care about details, as I am very good at details. It is approximation that is difficult.” This being the only criticism, following my request for a formal review, I would take it that Christopher’s character is equally believable to an autist. […] Anyone working with people, especially teens and preteens, with pervasive developmental disorders, and enjoying it, will also enjoy this book, as it is so familiarly and delightfully autistic. Those who have little experience with autists will learn a lot. I would highly recommend this to all professionals and parents who have an interest in this area. This story provides a wealth of information in an informative and yet informal fashion. Most of all – it is a good read!»

So after seeing all this positive opinions, here I have some that are not as positive as the ones above. This are the Texas Comunity reactions:

The novel was selected as a recommended book for the 2006 Galveston Reads program, a literacy encouragement program in Galveston County, Texas. Friendswood, Texas, Mayor Kimball Brizendine issued a proclamation declaring January 31 «Galveston County Reads Day» and encouraging «all citizens, teens to seniors» to read the novel. Five days later, he retracted the statement, declaring that it was «not [his] intention to endorse this readership [sic] for our younger readers.» The journal American Libraries reported, «City Council member Chris Peden went a step further, asserting to the January 28 Galveston County Daily News that while he hadn’t read Curious Incident in its entirety, he had noted that the ‘F word’ appeared on page four and that ‘later in the book, the [lead character] says there is no God and there is no life after death. Clearly, these are not ideas we should promote to kids».

In August, 2007, some parents in Bryan, Texas, «were appalled to see what their kids were reading» and protested the inclusion of the book in high school libraries, with one parent claiming that Curious Incident and another book (Catalyst by Laurie Halse Anderson) were «unsuitable for not just some but all high school students».

To finish this post, I have the negative opinion that I have spoken about before, and it is written by a father of an autist boy who has the syndrome.

«Boone describes himself as «a mathematician with some behavioural difficulties,» but despite this stylistic obfuscation, we’re not left to guess at his diagnosis. Early book jackets made explicitly clear that he has Asperger’s syndrome. […]  Asperger’s tends to be a relatively mild form of autistic spectrum disorder. Most aspies are «high-functioning.» They don’t refuse to go to school if they spy a yellow car, or curl up into a whimpering ball on a train because there are too many people around, as Boone does in Curious Incident. Indeed, if Christopher John Francis Boone has Asperger’s, as we’ve been led to believe, he has one of the most extreme forms of the disorder ever recorded.

He strengthen his statement saying that the only opinion that was put in a journal from an autist point of view was a positive one, but he had found that the majority of the people who suffered from the syndrome, opined completely different things:

««Stereotyped, inaccurate, horribly offensive… this isn’t how it is.» «Haddon does not understand Asperger.» «Stereotypical view of an autistic child.» «I find it hard to believe that Mark Haddon is an autism expert, because Christopher Boone isn’t like any other child with Asperger’s that I’ve ever met.» «A major disservice to the Autistic Community.» «An excellent portrayal of autism…NOT!»

The aspie reviewers, as it happens, were onto something. Haddon, by his own admission, is clueless about Asperger’s. «I know very little about the subject,» he confessed on his website, in an blog posted on July 16, 2009.»

He ends saying that he doesn’t «begrudge Haddon his freedom of speech, or his ability to make a living as a man of letters. He can write about whatever he pleases. What I find objectionable is that he seems unaware of — or, worse, indifferent toward — the fact that he has made both his name and his fortune exploiting the Asperger’s community, my son included.» and also that «Haddon did write an Asperger’s character, he did take advantage of the words «Asperger’s Syndrome» in his marketing campaign, and knowingly or not, he did create a negative stereotype. And if he felt anything but indifference toward this literary exploitation after the fact, he would not have used the same narrator-with-relatively-rare-psychological-disorder gimmick in his follow-up novel, as he did with 2006’s A Spot of Bother, replacing Asperger’s with hypochrondria. In any case, the damage is done. Christopher John Francis Boone is to Asperger’s what Raymond Babbitt is to autism. And aspies everywhere — including my son — must now live with it.»

So as we can see by all this opinions, there are plenty of good ones, but there are also negative ones that are not pleased with the book and that think that the author did not do a good work using the Asperger’s Syndrome to write a book that finally became a bestseller.

Publicado en Sin categoría | Deja un comentario